Showing posts with label Life in a Theocracy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Life in a Theocracy. Show all posts

Friday, November 30, 2007

Life in a Theocracy: Update, Government Goes ‘Soft’ on Teacher, Crowds Call for Death

Great Reuters video summary of the story

Remember Gillian Gibbons, The 54 year old British school teacher who allowed one of her students to name his teddy bear “Muhammad”? She was sentenced by Sudanese officials today. She’s been in jail for five days, since she was arrested shortly after the incident. Her punishment could have been a year in jail, 40 lashes or a fine. In the end, the government decided fifteen days in jail was appropriate. Excessive, but at least she’ll survive without being killed or something. Right? maybe…


Blasphemer and Heretic


When the news that the British school teacher “only” got fifteen days in prison was announced, up to a thousand marched in Sudan’s capital protesting for her death. The BBC reports:

According to some agencies, some of the protesters chanted: "Shame, shame on the UK", "No tolerance - execution" and "Kill her, kill her by firing squad".


This kindg of surprised me… The government takes a lenient (by regional standards) approach to the problem, she’s only serving 1/24 the maximum sentence. But the people get upset? On one hand this could be a small group of crazies, unrepresentative of the population. According to Wikipedia, there are 2.2 million people in the city, and another 6 million around the city. Some reports are emphatically claiming the number was in the “thousands”, but BBC claims it was about a thousand. In a city of that size, this protest seems relatively minor. Given the government’s lenient action, and the extraordinarily small scope of the protest, this could all go away once she’s released from prison and deported.

On the other hand, it only takes one person to kill her. Widespread outrage isn’t necessary for an assassination attempt. With the Sudanese Government’s theocratic tendencies and their absolute corruption, I’m sure she doesn’t feel safe in prison from those thousand, chanting for her death. Let’s hope she is able to get out of the country in one piece.

Wednesday, November 28, 2007

Life in a Theocracy: Teddy Bear Subversive pt. 1

The BBC reports, A British Teacher in Sudan allowed one of her students to name a teddy bear “Muhammad” in a class activity. Authorities, enforcing an Islamic command against representing Muhammad, arrested and charged her with Insulting Religion, Inciting Hate, and Showing Contempt for religious beliefs. If convicted, she could face 6 months in jail, 40 lashes, or a fine.

This nice lady?

Why does the state have a role to play here? It’s insulting on multiple levels. First and foremost, I am offended by the states authoritarian endorsement of one specific religion, which would not surprise anyone familiar with Sudan. Another facet of insult lies in the states regulation of religious rules. It is one thing to endorse one religion over all others; it’s another thing to become the punisher of religious violations. And it is an unbearable thing

I am insulted because when a government promotes one religion above all others squelches the debate. No longer is there a marketplace of ideas where bad ideas collide with better ideas, not in Sudan. In Muslim Theocracies, Islam is the only game in town. When a government doesn’t allow ideas to compete, traditions go unexamined, centuries old religious regulation created in a specific set of historical circumstances (complete female subjection, scientific ignorance, etc) continue to hold sway over modern times that are devoid of the context the rules were written in. The result is that the religion does not match the time and many of these Muslim Theocracies are the worse off for it. They govern poorly, authoritatively punishing their populations, and they eschew contact and trade with the west, that could help their economy.

More next post!

Life in a Theocracy: Teddy Bear Subversive pt. 2


This event reminds me of Salman Rushdie’s article, “Yes, This Is About Islam". In it, he makes the point that in the west, religion has faded into our private lives, we have individualized it. While in Islamic countries, religion is not private, it is public, it’s not only important what you do, and it is important what your neighbor does. He claims, and I agree, that this is the fundamental flaw with Islam that must be reformed if they are to enter the modern world.

These “Islamists” are using this event to whip up anti-west sentiment

"What has happened was not haphazard or carried out of ignorance, but rather a calculated action and another ring in the circles of plotting against Islam," the Sudanese Assembly of the Ulemas said in a statement.


We’ll see how it turns out. Given their countries history with dealing with large problems, my faith in their capacity to deal with this small problem is shaken to say the least. This is Religious Politics in Sudan, and at any given time we are one election away from this.

Sunday, November 25, 2007

Update: Saudi Foreign Minister: It’s ok that we punished that gang rape victim, she’s a whore!

When defending rape, imputing that the victim was promiscuous is a frequently used tactic. Today, the Saudi Arabian government issued a statement claiming that the woman who was gang raped 14 times earlier this month, was having an affair when she was raped. This was meant to mitigate the international outrage that occurred after news broke of the girl's story.

The minister claims that the woman has admitted to being in the act of intercourse with a man other than her husband, when she and her lover were gang raped at knife point. By releasing this information, the foreign minister believes it is somehow helping its case.

What is the Saudi government saying, “She was having an affair so she deserved it”? First of all, I don’t trust the Saudi government to fully report the truth when it is under international scrutiny. There is a good chance, this new fact is untrue. But even if it is true, it doesn’t matter. Her gang rape was still a terrible crime, and her punishment should still be nothing. If she was having an affair, than the state should leave it to them to sort it out, its simply not the governments job. The Saudi’s show how they completely miss the point by defending themselves like this.

Thursday, November 15, 2007

Life in a Theocracy: Woman Punished After Being Gang Raped

In an attempt to explain the importance of politics, and the remind cynics what is still good about our country, this blog will examine life in theocratic states.

By learning about the backwards and illiberal actions of tyrannical governments that blend religion and politics, we can remind ourselves of what’s at stake if we lose our democratic values.

Today, we examine the story of a 19 year old Saudi girl who was gang raped last week. As it turns out not only is she being punished for being in the car with men alone, but the sentence is being increased since she tried to use international media to help her situation.

She was gang-raped 14 times in the attack, and her punishment was 200 lashes, and a six-month prison sentence.

I don’t know what to feel worse about; her brutal gang-rape, the lack of balanced justice, her punishment… This is what happens with the thumbs of religious dogma are placed on the scales of justice.


Monday, November 12, 2007

Life in a Theocracy: Iran cracks down on “vices”.

In today’s installment of Life in a Theocracy, we travel to Persia where the Islamic government enforces Sharia law.

Maybe you’ve had to dress up for church, didn’t that suck? That’s the way it is in Iran, 24/7 now. Although there has been periods of liberal enforcement, the Iranian Police has announced renewed efforts to crack down on “vices”.

The police are warning they will deal seriously with any women who dare to wear short trousers, skimpy overcoats or skirts that are revealingly transparent or have slits in them.

Can you imagine being an Iranian Police officer, having to spend your timing judging the transparency of skirts and the skimpiness of overcoats? Do you think any of them signed up for that? The regulations continue…

Wearing boots instead of full length trousers will not be tolerated, nor will hats instead of headscarves. Indeed, the police stipulate that small headscarves are out - the scarf must cover a woman's head and neck completely.

The article doesn’t mention this but this crackdown occurred for two purposes. One establishes the dominance of Iranian patriarchal religious culture over women and their habits. When the Imams control women’s fashion, and sexual behavior, they control the society. Another purpose is to push back against the slow intrusion of western culture. Since western culture allows human nature its most free expression, western dress and trends constantly seep into Iranian society. This is repudiated by the government, sometimes in formal enforcement actions like this one. Both the power of women and western culture in Iran are threats to the ruling class, and as a result they were cracked down on. Increased repression shows that there is instability. We might be seeing the beginning of another revolutionary period in Iran.